What to actually say
Open with this, more or less word for word: It's really good to finally meet you both — I've heard so much, and now I get to match some of it to faces.
How did you two end up here, in this house, in this town?
Origin questions have legs — people can talk for five minutes on that without feeling interrogated, and it buys you real material instead of small talk you have to keep refilling.
I do accounting for a mid-size firm — the part I like is that no two months look the same, the part I don't is that nobody at a party knows what to do with that answer.
Naming what's dull about your own job before they can decide it's dull for you takes the air out of any judgment they were forming.
I try to keep that stuff off the table on the first meeting — ask me again in a year and I'll tell you straight.
It's honest that you're pacing yourself, not hiding forever, which reads as self-possessed rather than evasive.
This pot roast smell is incredible, by the way — [partner] wasn't exaggerating.
Using the room instead of your own cleverness fills a silence without making it about you filling it.
How it usually goes
A version of the conversation with the push-back left in, because that is the part you need to have already heard once.
What not to say
I'm not political at all, honestly.
It sounds like a dodge inside a dodge — claiming a blank slate makes people more curious, not less.
Well, I make about X a year, plus bonuses, so I'm not worried financially.
Answering the stability question with numbers turns a casual worry into an audit and makes you look like you're campaigning for the job of son-in-law.
This is honestly the best meal I've ever had in my life.
Said before you've taken a bite, it reads as buttering up, and people notice math that doesn't add up.
If they push on politics after you've already deflected once
Don't escalate and don't fully cave either — hold the same line with a bit more texture so it doesn't sound rehearsed. Say something like, 'I'll tell you honestly — I pay more attention to elections than I talk about them at dinner tables. Ask me on a walk sometime, not over pot roast.' That gives them a real answer about who you are (someone who follows it, not someone who's checked out) without opening a debate you can't win at a first meeting. If they push a third time, that's information about them, not a test you failed.